Psychology

Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking

Overview

Susan Cain, a former lawyer, argues that American culture in particular admires the outgoing, talkative person and treats quietness as a fault. She calls this the Extrovert Ideal and traces it to the early twentieth century. Using psychology research and interviews, she describes what introverts tend to do well, such as careful thinking and listening. She also gives advice for offices, schools and parents of quiet children.

In brief

The Extrovert Ideal

Cain says schools and workplaces are designed for people who like groups and quick talk. She cites estimates that between a third and a half of Americans are introverts.

Solitude and creative work

Cain questions group brainstorming and open-plan offices. She cites studies in which people working alone produced more ideas, and points to Steve Wozniak designing the first Apple computer largely by himself.

Introverts as leaders

Cain reports research by Adam Grant which found that introverted leaders got better results than extroverts when their staff were proactive, because they listened and let people run with ideas.

Different temperaments

Cain does not rank one type above the other. She advises couples, teams and teachers to allow for both, for instance by giving quiet people time to prepare before they speak.

Who should read this

Quiet people who have been told all their lives to speak up more, and the parents, teachers and managers who deal with them. Useful if you feel drained by group work or constant meetings.

Who might skip it

Skip if you're uncomfortable with popular-psychology books that rely heavily on a single personality axis — introversion-extroversion is one dimension of personality, and Cain sometimes treats it as more explanatory than it is. Skip also if you already identify strongly as an introvert and don't need further validation.

How talking became a measure of worth

Cain argues that modern Western culture, especially in America, treats the outgoing person as the model everyone should copy. She calls this the Extrovert Ideal.

She traces the change to the early twentieth century, borrowing from the historian Warren Susman. As people moved from small towns to cities and began working with strangers, a culture that admired character gave way to one that admired personality. Good conduct in private mattered less than the impression you made. Self-help books began teaching charm, and Dale Carnegie built a career on it.

Cain visits Harvard Business School, where students are graded on class participation and an active social life is close to compulsory. Her point is that confident speech gets mistaken for good thinking. She cites research suggesting that people who talk more in a group are rated as smarter, even when their ideas are no better.

Temperament starts early

Introversion is partly inborn. Cain leans on the work of the psychologist Jerome Kagan, who tested babies by exposing them to new sounds, sights and smells. Some reacted strongly, kicking and crying. Others stayed calm. When he followed the children over the years, the strongly reactive babies were more likely to grow into careful, quiet teenagers.

The explanation she offers is sensitivity to stimulation. Introverts are comfortable with less of it. A crowded wedding hall with loud music may delight one cousin and exhaust another within an hour, and neither is being difficult.

Temperament is not a life sentence, though. Cain describes personality as something like a rubber band. You can stretch yourself a good distance from your starting point, and many shy children become confident speakers. But there is a limit, and staying past it for long is tiring.

Working alone produces better ideas

Group brainstorming is popular, and Cain presents decades of studies showing it works poorly. People who think alone and then pool their ideas come up with more ideas, and better ones, than the same number of people brainstorming in a room. In groups some people sit back and let others work, and many hold back for fear of looking foolish.

She tells the story of Steve Wozniak, who designed the first Apple computer largely by himself, working early in the morning and late at night. She also draws on Anders Ericsson's research on expert performance. The kind of practice that builds real skill needs full concentration on the part you find hardest, and that is nearly always done alone. A student who studies with friends may enjoy it more, but the difficult chapters usually get learned in a quiet room.

Quiet leaders

Introverts can lead well, and in some situations they lead better. Cain reports research by Adam Grant which found that introverted leaders got stronger results when their team members were proactive. They listened to suggestions and let people run with them. Extroverted leaders did better with teams that waited to be told what to do, because they supplied the energy and direction.

The book opens with Rosa Parks, whose refusal to give up her bus seat in 1955 helped start the American civil rights movement. People who knew her described her as soft-spoken and timid. Cain pairs her with Martin Luther King Jr., a gifted speaker, to show that the movement needed both.

For a quiet person in a first job, preparation helps. Writing down two points before a meeting and raising one of them early works better than hoping for a gap in the conversation.

Acting outgoing when it matters

Introverts can behave like extroverts for the sake of work or people they care about. Cain explains this with Free Trait Theory, developed by the psychologist Brian Little. Little is a strong introvert who became a much loved university lecturer, lively and funny in front of a hall full of students. After his talks he would hide somewhere quiet to recover, on one occasion in a bathroom stall.

His theory says we are born with certain traits but can act against them in the service of what he calls core personal projects. A shy teacher can be bold in the classroom because teaching matters to her.

The cost is real, so Cain recommends restorative niches. These are places or pockets of time where you return to your natural self, such as a walk alone after lunch. She also suggests agreeing with family or colleagues how many social events you will attend, so that you do not have to argue about each one.

Raising and teaching quiet children

The final chapters are for parents and teachers. Cain asks them to stop treating a child's quietness as a fault to be corrected. A child who hangs back at a birthday party is usually watching and working out how things go, and will join in when ready. Calling them shy in front of others tends to make it worse.

She suggests introducing new situations gradually. Arrive early at a gathering so the room fills up around the child. Visit the new school before the first day.

She also discusses the idea that sensitive children are like orchids. They wilt more easily in a harsh setting, but with good care they may do better than their tougher classmates. For teachers, her advice is to balance group work with individual work. Even a few minutes of silent writing before a discussion gives quieter pupils a way in.

Try this week

  1. Before your next meeting or class discussion, write down two points and say one of them in the first ten minutes.
  2. Block one hour a day this week for work done alone with your phone in another room.
  3. After a tiring social event, plan thirty minutes by yourself instead of going straight into another commitment.
  4. If you run a team or a study group, ask everyone to write their ideas down individually before the discussion starts.

Our honest take

Cain uses the word introvert loosely, folding in shyness, sensitivity and seriousness, which is broader than the definition psychologists use. Most people sit somewhere in the middle, and the book sometimes reads as if there were two separate kinds of human. It can also flatter quiet readers more than it challenges them.

"There's zero correlation between being the best talker and having the best ideas."

— Susan Cain, Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking

If you liked this

Bittersweet, Cain's follow-up, is about the positive role of melancholy. For the clinical-grade version, read Big Five personality research overviews.

Questions readers ask

Is Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking worth reading?

Yes, especially if you are a quiet person who has spent years being told to speak up; it gives you the research and the words for what you already suspected. Bear in mind that it uses the word introvert very broadly and tends to flatter quiet readers rather than challenge them.

Who should read Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking?

Quiet people who have been told all their lives to speak up more, and the parents, teachers and managers who deal with them. Useful if you feel drained by group work or constant meetings.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play