Psychology

Outliers: The Story of Success

This summary is also available in Urdu. یہ خلاصہ اردو میں پڑھیں ←

Overview

Malcolm Gladwell looks at very successful people and asks what lay behind them besides talent. His answer is opportunity: the month and year of birth, family background, culture and the chance to practise for thousands of hours. He uses cases such as Canadian hockey players, Bill Gates and the Beatles. The book is built on stories, and researchers have disputed some of his conclusions, above all the 10,000-hour rule.

In brief

The 10,000-hour rule

Gladwell argues that top performers usually have around 10,000 hours of practice behind them. Anders Ericsson, whose research he relies on, later said the number was an average and not a rule.

Timing

Gladwell notes that many elite Canadian hockey players are born early in the year. As children they were the oldest in their age group, so they were picked for better teams and got more coaching.

Cultural legacy

Habits passed down through generations affect how people act, Gladwell argues. His examples include deference to superiors in aeroplane cockpits and a link he draws between rice farming and persistence at maths.

Accumulated advantage

A small early edge brings better teaching and more practice, which widens the gap each year. Gladwell uses the sociologist Robert Merton's name for this, the Matthew Effect.

Who should read this

Students and young professionals who believe success is only talent and hard work, and who blame themselves for every gap. Also useful for parents and teachers thinking about how to create chances for children.

Who might skip it

Skip if you want careful social science — Gladwell is a popularisation artist and his critics, including in academic psychology, have pointed out that he sometimes overstates. Particularly skip the 10,000 hours chapter if you've already read Peak by Ericsson, which tells the story with more nuance.

Success is never a solo effort

Gladwell's argument is that we explain success badly. We look at a successful person and ask what he is like, how clever and how hard-working. Gladwell says we should ask when and where he was born and what chances he received. Talent and effort matter, but they need circumstances that give them room.

His opening example is Canadian ice hockey. A large share of elite players are born in the first months of the year. The reason is the cut-off date for age groups, which is the first of January. A boy born in January plays against boys born late in the same year who are many months younger, and at nine or ten that is a big difference in size and coordination. The older boys look more talented, get picked for better teams and receive more coaching. After a few years they really are better.

He borrows a term from sociology, the Matthew Effect, for this pattern. A small early lead brings extra opportunity, which creates a bigger lead.

The ten thousand hours idea

The most famous chapter claims that people at the top of demanding fields have practised for a very long time, around ten thousand hours. Gladwell relies on a study by the psychologist Anders Ericsson of violin students at a music academy in Berlin. By the age of twenty, the best students had practised far more than the average ones.

The part people forget is what Gladwell does with this. His point is that ten thousand hours is an enormous amount of time, and almost nobody reaches it without unusual help. Bill Gates attended a private school in Seattle that gave students access to a computer terminal in 1968, when most universities had nothing like it, and he spent thousands of hours programming as a teenager. The Beatles played long sets night after night in clubs in Hamburg before they became famous. Both had talent and both worked extremely hard, and both also had a rare chance to put in the hours early.

Timing and birth year

Gladwell pushes the idea of luck further by looking at when people are born. Gates, Steve Jobs and several other founders of the computer industry were born within a couple of years of each other in the mid 1950s. That made them about twenty when the first personal computers appeared. They were old enough to act and young enough to have no job or family holding them back.

He tells a similar story about Joe Flom, a New York lawyer. Flom was Jewish, and the established law firms of his time would not hire him. He ended up doing the work those firms looked down on, including hostile company takeovers. When takeovers later became a huge business, he was one of the few lawyers who already knew how to handle them. What began as a disadvantage became an opening.

The conclusion Gladwell draws is that your birth year and the state of your industry shape what your effort can achieve, and nobody chooses either.

Why high intelligence is not enough

Gladwell argues that beyond a certain level, more IQ does not bring more success. He describes Lewis Terman, a psychologist who tracked a group of children with very high IQ scores through their lives. Terman expected them to become the leaders of their generation. Most went on to ordinary careers.

What matters in addition is practical intelligence, which means knowing what to say, to whom, and when. Gladwell compares Chris Langan, a man with an extraordinarily high IQ who grew up poor and left college after problems with paperwork and unhelpful officials, with the physicist Robert Oppenheimer, who talked his way out of serious trouble as a student.

He links this skill to upbringing, using the work of the sociologist Annette Lareau. She found that wealthier parents tend to teach children to speak up and question adults, while poorer parents more often let children grow on their own. A child taught to ask the teacher for help gains an advantage that is unrelated to cleverness.

The culture you inherit

The second half of the book argues that habits passed down over generations affect how people behave today. The most discussed example is Korean Air, which had a poor safety record in the 1980s and 1990s. Gladwell argues that one cause was deference. In a culture with great respect for rank, a junior officer found it hard to tell the captain plainly that he was making a mistake, and hinted instead. The airline improved after it retrained crews to speak directly and made English the language of the cockpit.

A second example is about mathematics. Gladwell suggests that students from rice-farming cultures in Asia do well partly because rice farming demanded long, careful work all year, which left behind a belief that effort pays. He adds that number words in Chinese are short and regular, which makes early counting easier.

He also looks at school holidays. Research in Baltimore found that poorer children learn about as much as richer ones during term but fall behind over the long summer break.

What to take from it

The book does not tell you how to become successful, though it is sometimes read that way. Its message is aimed at how we judge people and how we build institutions. If hockey leagues grouped children by birth month, more talent would be found. If schools gave poorer children more learning time, the gap would narrow. Gladwell describes KIPP, a school programme in New York that does this with longer days and shorter holidays.

For an individual reader the use is more modest. It helps you see your own situation clearly. A student from a small town who reaches university without coaching centres or English-medium schooling has covered more ground than the marks show. Someone who had every advantage can be honest about it.

It also suggests where to look for openings. Flom and Gates both gained from entering a field early, before it was respectable or crowded, and putting in the hours while others waited.

Try this week

  1. List three advantages you received without earning them, and one you can pass on to a younger student or colleague.
  2. Pick one skill that matters for your career and give it a fixed hour of practice each day this week.
  3. If you are confused in class or at work, ask the teacher or a senior one direct question instead of staying silent.
  4. When you see a senior making a mistake, say so clearly and politely instead of hinting.
  5. Use part of your next holiday for study or reading so that the break does not set you back.

Our honest take

The ten thousand hour rule is the weakest part. Anders Ericsson, whose research it rests on, said Gladwell oversimplified it: the figure was an average and not a threshold, and the kind of practice matters more than the total. Later studies have found that practice explains only part of the difference between performers. The cultural chapters, on Korean pilots and on rice farming and maths, have been criticised as stereotypes built on thin evidence, and throughout the book Gladwell picks cases that fit his argument and leaves out those that do not.

"Success is not a random act. It arises out of a predictable and powerful set of circumstances and opportunities."

— Malcolm Gladwell, Outliers: The Story of Success

If you liked this

Read Peak by Anders Ericsson for the rigorous version of the expertise chapter. Range by David Epstein is the thoughtful counter-argument.

Questions readers ask

Is Outliers: The Story of Success worth reading?

Yes, as long as you read it for its argument about luck and opportunity rather than for the ten thousand hour figure, which the researcher behind it says was oversimplified. It is an easy, story-driven read, and the stories are chosen to fit the case.

Who should read Outliers: The Story of Success?

Students and young professionals who believe success is only talent and hard work, and who blame themselves for every gap. Also useful for parents and teachers thinking about how to create chances for children.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, in English and Urdu, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play