Psychology

Mindset: The New Psychology of Success

This summary is also available in Urdu. یہ خلاصہ اردو میں پڑھیں ←

Overview

Carol Dweck, a psychologist at Stanford, describes two beliefs people hold about ability. In a fixed mindset, intelligence and talent are set at birth. In a growth mindset, they can be developed with effort, good methods and help. She argues that the belief affects how people deal with challenges and failure in school, sport, work and relationships. Later large studies found that teaching a growth mindset helps, but modestly.

In brief

Two mindsets

A person with a fixed mindset treats a hard task as a test that might expose them. With a growth mindset the same task is a chance to improve, so they are more willing to try.

Effort

In a fixed mindset, needing to work hard means you lack talent. Dweck argues the opposite. She also warns that effort alone is not enough without new strategies and advice from others.

Praising the process

In Dweck's studies, children praised for being clever later avoided harder problems. Children praised for their effort chose harder ones and kept going for longer.

Mindsets can change

Dweck says people can learn to notice their fixed-mindset reactions and answer them. She adds that everyone is a mixture of both, and that change takes practice.

Who should read this

Students who were labelled clever or weak early on and now believe the label, and the parents and teachers who hand out such labels. It also helps if you tend to avoid anything you might fail at.

Who might skip it

Skip if you want a short summary — the book is repetitive, and its argument can be compressed to a chapter. Also skip if you've read critical recent work (e.g., Sisk et al. 2018 meta-analysis) and want the conversation to engage those critiques; the book doesn't.

Two beliefs about ability

Dweck's claim is that what you believe about your own ability shapes how you behave when things get hard. In the fixed mindset, intelligence and talent are set amounts. You have a certain quantity and your job is to prove it. In the growth mindset, abilities can be developed through effort, better methods and help from other people. She does not say everyone can become anything. She says nobody knows in advance how far a person can go with years of training.

The idea came from her early research. She gave children a series of puzzles that became harder and watched how they handled the difficult ones. She expected some to cope with failure better than others. What she found was that some children did not seem to think they were failing at all. They enjoyed the hard puzzles and thought they were learning something. That surprised her, and she spent the following decades studying what separated those children from the ones who wanted to stop.

What effort and failure mean in each mindset

The two mindsets give opposite meanings to the same events. In the fixed mindset, needing effort is a bad sign, because truly talented people are supposed to find things easy. Failure is worse. It stops being something that happened and becomes a statement about who you are. So people protect themselves. They choose tasks they know they can do, or they stop trying so that a poor result can be blamed on not caring.

Take a boy known in his family as the one who is good at maths. In class he stops asking questions, because asking would show that he did not understand. He avoids the hardest problems in the book for the same reason. Over two years, the label that was meant to encourage him makes him weaker at the subject. In the growth mindset a bad mark still hurts, and Dweck is clear about that. It is read as information about what to work on next.

The trouble with praising intelligence

The best known research in the book is about praise. Dweck and her colleagues gave children a set of problems and then praised them in one of two ways. Some were told they must be smart. Others were told they must have worked hard. When offered a choice afterwards, the children praised for being smart tended to pick the easier task, where they could keep looking clever. When the problems became difficult, they enjoyed them less and their performance dropped. Some of them overstated their scores when asked to report them to other children.

Her advice to parents and teachers follows from this. Praise what the child did, such as the method used or the number of attempts, and avoid praise for being gifted. A mother who tells relatives that her daughter is so bright she never needs to study is setting a trap. The first time the girl does need to study, she will feel she has lost the thing she was admired for.

Talent in sport and business

Dweck shows the same pattern among adults. In sport, she argues against the idea of the natural. Michael Jordan is her main example of a growth mindset. He did not make his high school's top team at first, and he became known for practising the weakest parts of his game after every setback. The tennis champion John McEnroe is her example of the other kind. By her account he believed in talent, disliked having to work at things, and blamed outside causes when he lost.

In business she points to Enron, a company that hired for brilliance and praised it constantly. In that kind of culture, she argues, admitting a mistake felt like confessing you were not talented after all, so problems stayed hidden. She contrasts leaders who needed to be the biggest person in the room with leaders who listened to their teams and were willing to hear bad news.

Marriage, friendship and teaching

The fixed mindset also affects how people treat each other. In marriage and friendship, it shows up as the belief that a good relationship should need no work, and that a disagreement proves something is wrong with the other person. Dweck says people in a growth mindset are more willing to talk about problems, because a problem is something to solve and says nothing final about either person.

For teachers the lesson is about standards. She describes teachers such as Marva Collins in Chicago, who took children that schools had given up on and taught them demanding material, including Shakespeare. These teachers did not lower the bar to protect feelings. They kept it high and then showed students how to reach it. Dweck thinks both common alternatives fail. Telling a weak student he is doing fine is a lie he will eventually discover, and demanding high marks without teaching him how to study only produces fear.

Changing your mindset, and the false version

Mindsets are beliefs, and Dweck argues that beliefs can be changed. In the updated edition she adds a warning. Many people now claim to have a growth mindset when they simply mean they are open-minded, or they praise effort even when the effort is producing no learning. She calls this a false growth mindset. If working hard with one method is not helping, the answer is to try a different method or ask for help.

She also says nobody is purely one type. Everyone is a mixture, and certain situations bring out the fixed side, such as being criticised or meeting someone far better than you at your own subject. Her practical suggestion is to learn your own triggers and give that fixed-mindset voice a name. When it appears, you answer it the way you would answer a worried relative who does not want you to take a risk.

Try this week

  1. Notice one thing this week that you are avoiding because you might look bad at it, and do a small version of it anyway.
  2. When you praise a child or a junior colleague, name what they did, such as the method or the hours, and leave out words like gifted or genius.
  3. After your next poor mark or piece of criticism, write down two things you will do differently before you write down any excuse.
  4. List the situations that bring out your fixed side, and give that voice a name so you can recognise it when it speaks.
  5. Pick one skill you have always said you are not made for, and spend twenty minutes a day on it for a week using a method you have not tried before.

Our honest take

The idea is simple and the book stretches it across many chapters of stories about athletes and executives, most of them chosen after the fact to fit the pattern. More seriously, later large studies and reviews have found that the link between mindset and school results, and the effect of teaching a growth mindset, are much smaller than the book suggests, with the clearest gains among students who were already struggling. The book also says little about circumstances. A student in a poor school with no money for books is held back by more than a belief.

"Becoming is better than being. The fixed mindset does not allow people the luxury of becoming."

— Carol S. Dweck, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success

If you liked this

For the careful research version, read Peak by Ericsson. For the critique, search for Carl Hendrick's essays on the growth-mindset evidence.

Questions readers ask

Is Mindset: The New Psychology of Success worth reading?

Yes, as a short idea worth knowing, especially for parents and teachers; the early chapters and the one on praise carry most of it. The evidence is weaker than the book implies, so treat it as a useful habit of thought and not a cure for poor results.

Who should read Mindset: The New Psychology of Success?

Students who were labelled clever or weak early on and now believe the label, and the parents and teachers who hand out such labels. It also helps if you tend to avoid anything you might fail at.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, in English and Urdu, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play