Psychology

Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion

Overview

Robert Cialdini, a social psychologist, spent years studying why people agree to requests, including time spent training alongside salespeople, fundraisers and advertisers. The original book, from 1984, names six principles: reciprocity, commitment and consistency, social proof, liking, authority and scarcity. A later edition adds a seventh, unity. He explains each with experiments and examples, and gives advice on how to refuse.

In brief

Reciprocity

People feel they must repay a gift or favour, even one they did not ask for. Cialdini shows how free samples and small gifts from charities use this to get larger returns.

Scarcity

We want things more when they are rare or about to run out. Cialdini says limited offers and deadlines work because people hate to lose a chance they already had.

Social proof

When unsure what to do, people copy those around them. Cialdini's examples include recorded laughter on television and bystanders who fail to help because nobody else is helping.

Authority

People tend to obey those who look like experts. Cialdini cites Stanley Milgram's obedience experiments and notes that titles, uniforms and expensive clothes can trigger the same response.

Commitment and consistency

After taking a small step or stating a position, people feel pressure to act in line with it. Salespeople use this by getting a small yes before asking for a bigger one.

Who should read this

Anyone who has bought something they did not need or agreed to a request and regretted it later. Also useful for people in sales or fundraising who want to persuade honestly.

Who might skip it

Skip if you've already internalised the six principles through business or marketing training — the original is still the best version, but you may not need it. Skip also if you dislike the 'compliance professional' anecdotes; some of them now feel dated.

Why we say yes without thinking

Most of our decisions are made on shortcuts. We do not have the time to analyse every choice, so we rely on simple rules such as expensive means good, or an expert probably knows best. Cialdini's subject is what happens when someone uses them against us.

He opens with a jewellery shop owner who could not sell a batch of turquoise. She left a note telling her assistant to cut the price by half. The assistant misread it and doubled the price, and the stones sold out. Tourists who knew little about turquoise took price as a sign of quality.

He also describes an experiment by Ellen Langer in which people asking to jump the queue at a photocopier did far better when they gave a reason, even an empty one. Cialdini spent nearly three years taking training courses with salespeople, fundraisers and advertisers, and organises what he found into six principles.

Reciprocity and the small favour

People feel a strong obligation to repay what they have been given, even when they did not ask for it. This allows cooperation, since you can give something away and trust it will come back. It also opens the door to exploitation, because the first gift can be small and the return favour much larger.

Cialdini describes members of the Hare Krishna movement handing a flower to travellers at airports before asking for a donation. Many people who did not want the flower gave money anyway.

A second version is the concession. If someone makes a large request, is refused, and then backs down to a smaller one, the other person feels pressure to give something in return. In one of his own studies, students were asked to accompany young offenders on a trip to the zoo. Far more agreed when they had first refused a much bigger request.

Commitment and the wish to be consistent

Once we have taken a position, we feel pressure to behave in line with it. Being seen as inconsistent is uncomfortable, so a small first step can lead to a much larger one.

The classic study Cialdini describes was carried out in California. Researchers asked homeowners to put a large, ugly sign about safe driving in their front gardens. Most refused. But in a group that had earlier agreed to display a tiny sign with a similar message, the majority said yes. The first small act had changed how they saw themselves.

Commitments have most force when they are written down and made in public. Salespeople know this, which is why they ask the customer to fill in the order form. Cialdini's defence is to notice the tight feeling in your stomach when you are being pushed into something you would not choose again.

Following the crowd

When we are unsure what to do, we look at what others are doing. Cialdini calls this social proof. It explains why television comedies use recorded laughter. Viewers say they dislike it, yet they laugh more when it is there.

Social proof is strongest when the situation is unclear and when the other people seem similar to us. It can fail badly in emergencies. If a person collapses on a busy street, each passer-by looks at the others, sees nobody reacting and decides it cannot be serious. Cialdini gives direct advice for anyone who needs help in a crowd. Pick out one person and tell them exactly what you need, such as calling an ambulance.

Online reviews and follower counts are today's version of the same principle, and they can be faked as easily as recorded laughter.

Liking and authority

We agree more readily with people we like and with people who appear to be in charge. On liking, Cialdini shows that good looks, similarity, compliments and familiarity all raise the chance of a yes. His example is the Tupperware party, where the request to buy comes from a friend hosting the event and not from the company.

On authority, he discusses Stanley Milgram's experiments, in which ordinary volunteers followed a researcher's instructions to give what they believed were painful electric shocks to another person. The symbols of authority are often enough. Titles and uniforms produce deference, and an advertisement with an actor in a white coat borrows the standing of a doctor.

He recommends checking whether the person is truly an expert on this particular subject, and whether they have something to gain from your agreement.

Scarcity and the fear of missing out

Things seem more valuable when they are hard to get. The thought of losing an opportunity moves people more than the thought of gaining something of equal value. Sellers use this with limited stock and deadlines. Online shops do it with messages saying only two items are left.

Cialdini describes an experiment in which people tasted cookies from a jar. When the jar held only two, the cookies were rated as more desirable than the same cookies from a full jar. They were not rated as tasting any better.

The effect is stronger still when we are competing with others, which is the mood of a crowded sale. His advice is to treat the rush of excitement as a warning sign and then to think about why you want the item. If you want it for use, it will work equally well whether it is rare or common.

Try this week

  1. Before any large purchase, wait twenty-four hours, especially if the offer has a countdown timer.
  2. When a seller gives you something free, decide whether you would want the product if the gift had never been offered.
  3. If you need help in a public place, address one specific person and tell them exactly what to do.
  4. Before trusting an expert in an advertisement, check whether they are qualified in that subject and whether they are being paid.

Our honest take

Many of the experiments are decades old and were run on small groups of Americans, and some well-known findings in social psychology have proved hard to repeat. The effects are usually smaller in real life than the stories suggest. The book also sits in an awkward place, since it is sold as a defence against manipulation and read by many as a manual for it.

"A well-known principle of human behavior says that when we ask someone to do us a favor we will be more successful if we provide a reason."

— Robert B. Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion

If you liked this

Pre-Suasion, Cialdini's follow-up. For related ground with different angles, Yes! by Noah Goldstein (also with Cialdini).

Questions readers ask

Is Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion worth reading?

Yes. It is one of the few psychology books whose lessons you can use the next time a seller or a charity approaches you, and the stories make the six principles easy to remember. Just keep in mind that the experiments are old and the effects in daily life are smaller than the book makes them sound.

Who should read Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion?

Anyone who has bought something they did not need or agreed to a request and regretted it later. Also useful for people in sales or fundraising who want to persuade honestly.

How long does this summary take to read?

About 5 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.

Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.

Get the app

Share your thoughts

Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.

Read summaries offline in the free app MyByteNest for Android: 268 book summaries, 50 of them in depth, some in Urdu. No sign-up and no subscription.
Get it on Google Play