Overview
Benjamin Graham first published this guide for ordinary investors in 1949 and revised it several times. Warren Buffett, his student, called it by far the best book on investing ever written. Graham teaches value investing: treat a share as part of a business, work out what the business is worth, and buy only well below that price. He sorts readers into defensive and enterprising investors and advises each differently.
In brief
Margin of safety
Graham's central idea is to pay much less than your estimate of a company's value. The gap protects you when the estimate is wrong or luck turns, which he assumes will happen.
Mr. Market
Graham imagines a business partner who offers every day to buy your share or sell you his, at prices set by his mood. You can ignore him, or deal when his price suits you.
Investor and speculator
An investment, in Graham's definition, promises safety of principal and an adequate return after thorough analysis. Anything else is speculation. He says to keep any speculating separate and small.
Diversifying and patience
Graham advises the defensive investor to hold a spread of large, sound companies and to keep between a quarter and three quarters of the portfolio in shares, with the rest in bonds.
Who should read this
Anyone about to put savings into shares for the first time, or anyone who has already lost money following tips. It suits patient readers who want a way of thinking and not a list of stocks to buy.
Who might skip it
Skip if you want a modern index-fund treatment — Graham was writing before index funds existed, and the book's specific stock-picking methods (net-net, etc.) are harder to apply in today's markets. Skip also if you want short; the book is long and deliberately unhurried.
Investing and speculating are different things
Graham begins by separating two activities that people confuse. An investment, in his definition, is made after thorough analysis, protects the money you put in and offers an adequate return. Anything that does not meet those conditions is speculation.
Buying a share because the price has been rising, or because someone in a WhatsApp group says it will double, is speculation. Buying it after studying the company's earnings, debts and assets, at a price that makes sense against those numbers, is investment. The same share can be either, depending on the price paid and the reasoning behind it.
Graham does not forbid speculation. He says that if you must do it, keep it to a small part of your money in a separate account. The danger he sees is people speculating while believing they are investing.
Mr. Market
Graham's best known idea is a story about an imaginary business partner. Suppose you own a share in a private business along with a man called Mr. Market. Every day he comes to you and names a price at which he will buy your share or sell you his. Some days he is cheerful and quotes a very high price. Other days he is gloomy and quotes a very low one. The business itself has hardly changed.
You are free to ignore him. He will come back tomorrow with a new price. If his price is foolishly high, you may sell to him. If it is foolishly low, you may buy. What you should not do is let his mood decide what you think your share is worth.
The stock market is Mr. Market. Graham's point is that price swings are there to be used and should not be taken as instructions.
Margin of safety
If Graham had to sum up sound investing in a few words, he says, they would be margin of safety. The idea is to buy only when the price is well below your estimate of what the business is worth. The gap is your protection.
An engineer designing a bridge for ten-tonne lorries builds it to hold far more, because calculations can be off and unexpected things happen. Your estimate of a company's value will never be exact. If you pay 60 for something you believe is worth 100, you can be quite wrong and still not lose money. If you pay 95, there is no room for error.
This is why Graham cares so much about the price paid. A sound business bought at too high a price can be a poor investment.
The defensive investor
Graham divides investors into two types according to how much time and effort they are willing to give. The defensive investor wants safety and freedom from bother. Most people belong in this group, and Graham does not look down on it.
His plan is simple. Divide your money between high-grade bonds and a diversified set of shares in large, well-established companies. He suggests an even split as a starting point, with shares never falling below a quarter or rising above three quarters of the total. When the market climbs and shares become too large a portion, sell some and restore the balance.
He also describes putting in the same amount of money at regular intervals, whatever the market is doing. In the commentary added to later editions, the financial journalist Jason Zweig says that for most people today a low-cost index fund does the defensive investor's job.
The enterprising investor
The enterprising investor is willing to treat investing as a part-time business. Graham warns that this route demands real work and offers no guarantee of better results. He states plainly that the return you can expect depends on the intelligent effort you put in. It does not depend on how much risk you take.
For those who choose this path, he suggests looking where others are not looking, such as large companies that are temporarily out of favour. These bargains were easier to find in his time than they are now.
He lists what to avoid as well. New share issues are usually sold when the market is hot and the terms favour the seller. Frequent trading runs up costs.
Graham's warning is that there is no comfortable middle. A person who puts in a little effort and expects a little extra return usually does worse than the defensive investor who does nothing clever.
Temperament decides the result
Graham believed that an investor's results depend more on character than on intelligence. He writes that the investor's main problem, and even his worst enemy, is likely to be himself. People with average ability and steady nerves often do better than brilliant people who cannot sit still.
The typical errors are emotional. People buy after prices have risen because everyone is excited, and sell after prices have fallen because everyone is afraid. They follow tips, and they borrow money to buy shares. Graham's whole method, including the fixed split between bonds and shares, is designed to protect investors from their own impulses.
He expects share prices to fall by a third or more from their high point from time to time. An investor who could not bear to watch that happen should hold fewer shares from the start.
Try this week
- Before buying any share, write down in three sentences what the business does, what it earns and why the price is reasonable.
- Decide your split between shares and safer holdings, write it down, and set a date every six months to rebalance.
- Stop checking share prices daily and limit yourself to once a week.
- Ignore any tip that arrives through a WhatsApp group unless you have read the company's annual report yourself.
Our honest take
Graham last revised the book in the early 1970s, and the companies, bond yields and tax rules he discusses belong to another era. The kind of obvious bargain he hunted for is rare now that information is cheap and fast. His advice on bonds assumes an American market, and readers who avoid interest-bearing investments will have to adapt that half of the plan.
"The investor's chief problem, and even his worst enemy, is likely to be himself."
— Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor
If you liked this
A Random Walk Down Wall Street for the index-fund alternative view. The Little Book of Common Sense Investing by Bogle for the shorter modern classic.
Questions readers ask
Is The Intelligent Investor worth reading?
Yes, if you are about to invest savings and want a way of thinking that will stop you chasing tips; the chapters on Mr. Market, margin of safety and temperament are why the book has lasted. The detailed examples are from the 1970s, so skim those and read Zweig's commentary for the modern picture.
Who should read The Intelligent Investor?
Anyone about to put savings into shares for the first time, or anyone who has already lost money following tips. It suits patient readers who want a way of thinking and not a list of stocks to buy.
How long does this summary take to read?
About 5 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.
Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.
Get the app
Share your thoughts
Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.