Overview
Harari follows Sapiens with a book about the future. He starts from the claim that famine, plague and war, though not gone, have become manageable problems. He then suggests what humanity will aim for next: longer life, engineered happiness and godlike powers. Much of the book discusses how biotechnology and artificial intelligence could weaken the belief in individual free choice. He presents these as possibilities, not predictions.
In brief
Dataism
Harari describes a belief that the universe consists of data flows and that the value of anything lies in its contribution to data processing. He thinks it may become a new creed.
The useless class
Harari suggests that if machines outperform people at most tasks, many could become unemployable. The label is his own, and economists disagree about how likely this outcome is.
Upgrading humans
Medicine may move from healing the sick to improving the healthy. Harari warns that if only the rich can afford such upgrades, the gap between classes could become biological.
The end of humanism
Humanism holds that human feelings and choices are the highest authority. Harari argues that if algorithms come to know us better than we know ourselves, that authority will pass to them.
Who should read this
Readers who wonder where artificial intelligence and biotechnology might take society, and students who like big arguments that link history, science and politics.
Who might skip it
Skip if you're short on time — Homo Deus has less internal discipline than Sapiens and sprawls. Skip also if you've read Sapiens recently; the first hundred pages are a partial recap. The predictions about social media as a 'new religion' already look dated.
The old problems are fading
For most of history people worried about famine, plague and war, and prayed for relief because they could do little else. Harari argues that in recent decades these have become manageable problems. They still kill, but they are no longer mysterious forces beyond human control.
He supports this with comparisons. More people now die from eating too much than from eating too little. More die of old age than of infectious disease. More die by suicide than are killed by soldiers, terrorists and criminals put together.
His point is that success creates new ambitions. Having reduced hunger, disease and violence, humanity will look for bigger goals. He suggests they will be to defeat ageing and death, to engineer lasting happiness, and to upgrade humans with abilities once reserved for gods. He says clearly that this is a set of possibilities and not a prophecy, written so people can choose differently.
How humans came to rule
Before looking forward, Harari explains why humans dominate the planet. His answer, carried over from his earlier book Sapiens, is that we are the only animals able to cooperate flexibly in very large numbers. We manage it because we can believe in shared stories. Money, nations, companies and laws exist only because millions of people agree that they do.
A thousand-rupee note is a good example. The paper has almost no value. It works because the shopkeeper, the bank and the customer all trust it.
He spends much of this part on animals. Humans have reshaped the lives of farm animals to suit our needs, with little concern for what they feel. If a more capable kind of being appears, whether upgraded humans or intelligent machines, how we treated less capable creatures may hint at how we will be treated.
Humanism and the authority of feelings
Harari argues that modern society runs on a belief system he calls humanism. In earlier ages, authority came from God or scripture. Over the last few centuries it moved to human experience.
He shows how far this goes. In politics, the voter knows best. In the economy, the customer is always right. In art, beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Each rests on the assumption that a person's inner feelings and free choices are the final source of meaning.
He describes the bargain behind modern life as giving up meaning in exchange for power. Older societies believed they were part of a cosmic plan, which gave life a purpose and also limits. Modern people gave up the plan and gained the freedom to change the world through science and economic growth. Humanism filled the gap by saying that humans create meaning themselves.
Organisms as algorithms
The second half turns on a claim from the life sciences. Harari says biology increasingly treats living things, humans included, as algorithms: sets of biochemical processes shaped by evolution to make decisions. If that is right, then feelings are calculations, and free will looks doubtful.
He also questions the idea of a single, unified self. Drawing on psychology experiments, he separates an experiencing self that lives each moment from a narrating self that makes up a tidy story afterwards. The storyteller often gets things wrong, and it is the one making our decisions.
If feelings are data processing, a system with enough data about your body and behaviour could understand your choices better than you do. He mentions the actress Angelina Jolie, who chose preventive surgery on the basis of a genetic test, as a case of trusting data over how she felt at the time.
Intelligence without consciousness
Harari's central warning is that intelligence is coming apart from consciousness. Until now, high intelligence always came with feelings and awareness. Computers are showing that tasks such as driving, diagnosing illness or playing chess can be done very well with no awareness at all.
He sees two dangers. The first is economic. If machines outperform people at most jobs, a large number of people may have no economic role. He calls this possible group the useless class. Armies and factories once needed masses of people, which gave ordinary citizens bargaining power. That power could fade.
The second is inequality of a new kind. If medicine moves from healing the sick to upgrading the healthy, wealthy people may buy better memory, health or lifespan. The gap between rich and poor could become biological.
For a student choosing a career today, his argument suggests expecting to retrain several times and not relying on one qualification for life.
Dataism and the closing questions
Harari ends with two belief systems that might replace humanism. Techno-humanism wants to keep humans at the centre by upgrading our minds and bodies with technology. Dataism goes further. It holds that the universe consists of flows of data, and that the value of anything lies in its contribution to data processing. In that view, humans are one processing system among many and may be overtaken by better ones.
He notes how readily people already feed the system, sharing their location, purchases and thoughts in exchange for convenience.
He closes by leaving readers with questions to think over. They ask whether living things really are just algorithms, whether intelligence or consciousness is more valuable, and what happens to society and daily life when unconscious but highly capable algorithms know us better than we know ourselves.
Try this week
- Check the privacy settings on the two apps you use most and turn off any data sharing you do not need.
- For one week, notice each time you follow an app's suggestion and note whether you would have chosen the same yourself.
- Write down which parts of your job or studies a computer could already do, and which parts need human judgement.
- Pick one skill outside your main field and spend an hour on it this week.
Our honest take
Harari presents the view that organisms are algorithms as settled science, when it is a disputed position that many scientists and philosophers reject. His confidence that epidemics and war were coming under control was written before the COVID-19 pandemic and looks too optimistic now. He covers huge subjects in a few pages each, and specialists often object to the simplifications. Because he calls his forecasts possibilities, they are also impossible to prove wrong.
"In the twenty-first century, those who ride the train of progress will acquire divine abilities of creation and destruction, while those left behind will face extinction."
— Yuval Noah Harari, Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow
If you liked this
21 Lessons for the 21st Century, Harari's third book, is weaker still. For serious futurism, try Superintelligence by Bostrom or The Singularity Is Near by Kurzweil.
Questions readers ask
Is Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow worth reading?
Yes, if you like big arguments that tie history, science and politics together and want a clear statement of where biotechnology and artificial intelligence might lead. Read it as one writer's provocation rather than a forecast: he treats the idea that organisms are algorithms as settled when it is disputed, he simplifies huge subjects, and his claim that plague and war were coming under control has aged badly since the pandemic.
Who should read Homo Deus: A Brief History of Tomorrow?
Readers who wonder where artificial intelligence and biotechnology might take society, and students who like big arguments that link history, science and politics.
How long does this summary take to read?
About 6 minutes. It covers the book's 6 main ideas, who it is for, what to try this week, and an honest view of its weak points.
Read it offline, or listen to it. This summary is in the free MyByteNest app for Android, with 267 others. No sign-up.
Get the app
Share your thoughts
Found a mistake, disagree with the verdict, or have a book to recommend? Email us at support@mybytenest.com — we read everything.